Post-tax deductions: A guide for US employers

As a US employer, understanding payroll deductions is crucial, especially when it comes to post-tax deductions. These often-overlooked deductions play a significant role in ensuring payroll compliance and employee satisfaction. Yet, many employers struggle to differentiate between pre-tax and post-tax deductions, leading to payroll mistakes that could affect compliance, taxes, and employee take-home pay.

In this article, we’ll dive deep into post-tax deductions, offer common examples, and share best practices for managing them. We’ll also show how you can simplify payroll compliance using Remote’s global employment solutions.

What are post-tax deductions?

Post-tax deductions are payroll deductions taken out of an employee's paycheck after taxes have been withheld. Unlike pre-tax deductions, which reduce taxable income, post-tax deductions don't provide tax benefits, but they are essential for managing certain employee benefits and legal obligations.

By understanding these deductions, you can manage payroll more accurately, improve compliance, and ensure your employees understand how their benefits affect their take-home pay.

Examples of post-tax deductions 

Let’s take a closer look at some of the most common post-tax deductions employers handle:

1. Health insurance premiums (after-tax)

While many health insurance premiums are eligible for pre-tax deductions, certain voluntary or supplemental plans require post-tax contributions. These might include optional vision or dental insurance or additional life insurance.

2. Union dues

For unionized employees, union dues are deducted post-tax based on the agreement with the labor union. Employers need to ensure accurate deductions to remain compliant with union contracts.

3. Roth IRA contributions

Unlike traditional 401(k) contributions that reduce taxable income, Roth IRA contributions are post-tax. This gives employees the benefit of tax-free withdrawals in retirement, but it requires employers to handle these deductions separately from pre-tax retirement contributions.

4. Wage garnishments

Employers may be legally required to deduct wages for court-ordered garnishments, such as child support, unpaid debts, or tax levies. Failure to comply with wage garnishment orders can result in hefty fines for employers.

5. Disability and life insurance premiums (after-tax)

Voluntary disability and life insurance premiums often fall under post-tax deductions. It’s crucial to manage these accurately to avoid any confusion on employee paychecks.

6. Other voluntary benefits

Other deductions, such as gym memberships or charity donations, also come out after taxes are applied. While these may seem small, managing them accurately shows a commitment to supporting employee well-being.

Tax and Compliance —

7 min

Payroll tax forms: A beginner’s guide for US employers

If you have employees in the US, here are the relevant payroll tax forms you need to be aware of — as well as how you can simplify the entire form-filling process.

How post-tax deductions affect employee take-home pay

To better understand the impact of post-tax deductions, let’s break down an employee paycheck.

In this example, an employee earning $5,000/month has:

• Pre-tax deductions: $500 (for 401(k) and health insurance).

• Taxes: $1,000.

• Post-tax deductions: $200 (for Roth IRA and union dues).

Final take-home pay: $3,300

Employers should communicate these deductions to employees, ensuring they understand the difference between pre-tax and post-tax contributions. Providing employees with a detailed breakdown of their paychecks helps avoid confusion and frustration.

Pro tip: Clear communication about post-tax deductions during onboarding and on paychecks improves transparency and employee trust.

Compliance and legal considerations for post-tax deductions

Failing to manage post-tax deductions correctly can lead to compliance issues, especially with the IRS or state labor laws. For example, mismanaging wage garnishments could result in penalties or legal action.

Tax implications

Post-tax deductions don't reduce taxable income but must still be reported correctly to the IRS. This includes accurate reporting of Roth IRA contributions, union dues, and voluntary benefits.

Regulatory compliance

Employers need to be aware of both federal and state regulations around payroll deductions. This is particularly important when handling court-ordered garnishments or union dues, as mistakes can lead to significant fines.

Best practices for managing post-tax deductions

Accurate management of post-tax deductions is key to maintaining compliance and ensuring payroll runs smoothly.

Payroll software integration. Automating post-tax deduction management through payroll software can help reduce errors, ensure compliance, and simplify tax reporting.

Regular payroll audits. Conducting regular payroll audits is critical for catching errors and ensuring accurate deductions. This practice can save your company from potential fines or employee disputes.

Employee communication. Open communication about payroll, especially deductions, fosters transparency and trust. Clearly explaining deductions—both during onboarding and on paychecks—will help employees feel confident in their compensation.

Tax and Compliance —

16 min

How payroll tax compliance software benefits your business

Learn about the challenges of payroll tax compliance, common consequences of noncompliance, and how to stay compliant using a payroll service.

How Remote helps manage payroll and tax compliance globally

Understanding and properly managing post-tax deductions is essential for US employers to stay compliant and maintain accurate payroll. Whether you’re handling Roth IRA contributions, wage garnishments, or other voluntary benefits, getting it right is critical for both compliance and employee satisfaction.

Managing payroll across borders adds complexity, especially when dealing with different tax laws and regulations. That’s where Remote’s global employment solutions come in.

We provide tools to manage both pre-tax and post-tax deductions, ensuring compliance with local laws, no matter where your employees are located. From handling payroll to benefits and deductions, Remote’s platform makes it easy to stay compliant, regardless of your employees’ location.

For more in-depth information on payroll management and tax compliance, download our Global Tax Management Guide. If you’re ready to streamline your payroll processes, book a demo with Remote to see how we can help simplify payroll and tax management globally.

Trust G2’s multi-country payroll leader to keep you compliant

Hire and pay your global team with Remote and get access to our team of global taxation experts.

Get started nowSchedule a demo