10 costly recruiting mistakes (and how to avoid them)

Hiring the right talent is one of the most critical challenges for any company. Yet, even experienced recruiters and hiring managers make mistakes that can lead to wasted time, high turnover, and poor hires.

The good news? Many recruiting mistakes are preventable. Whether you're hiring locally or remote team members, avoiding these common pitfalls will save your company money, time, and frustration.

Let’s break down 10 costly recruiting mistakes‌ — ‌and how you can fix them.

1. Rushing the hiring process 

When a key role opens up, the pressure to fill it quickly can be overwhelming. But rushing to hire often leads to high turnover and long-term costs.

What to do instead: 

• Define the role and its key competencies before starting recruitment.

• Take the time to vet candidates properly.

• Use structured interviews and skills assessments instead of relying on gut feelings.

A strategic hiring process prevents costly mistakes and helps you find the best talent.

2. Writing vague or unrealistic job descriptions 

A poorly written job description attracts the wrong candidates‌ — ‌or worse, discourages the right ones from applying.

What to do instead: 

• Be clear and specific about job responsibilities and expectations.

• Avoid jargon or vague terms like "rockstar" or "ninja.” Use language that clearly defines skills and experience.

• Highlight opportunities for growth and flexibility, especially for remote roles.

A well-crafted job post helps attract top talent while reducing unqualified applications.

3. Ignoring employer branding

Candidates research companies before they apply. If your online presence is weak‌ — ‌or worse, if your company has bad reviews‌ — ‌your company won’t attract top talent. 

What to do instead: 

• Build a strong employer brand through social media, employee testimonials, and a great careers page.

• Showcase your company culture, mission, and values in job postings.

• Respond to reviews on job platforms — both positive and negative.

A strong employer brand attracts high-quality candidates and makes recruiting easier.

4. Overlooking diversity and inclusion 

Hiring the same type of candidates over and over leads to stagnant teams and missed opportunities. A lack of diversity limits innovation and reduces performance.

What to do instead: 

• Use blind resume screening to minimize bias.

• Train hiring managers on inclusive hiring practices.

• Focus on building diverse teams.

5. Relying too much on resumes and credentials 

A strong resume doesn’t always mean a strong hire. Traditional credentials (like a prestigious degree) don’t guarantee skills, adaptability, or a good cultural fit.

What to do instead: 

• Use skills assessments instead of just reviewing resumes.

• Look for soft skills like problem-solving, adaptability, and communication.

• Hire for potential and growth, not just past job titles.

Global HR —

7 min

How to elevate your HR management with a skills matrix

Learn how to effectively develop your workforce using a skills matrix. Discover how to build your own skills matrix through our step-by-step guide, or use our sample skills matrix to elevate your HR management strategy.

6. Conducting poor interviews

Interviews are the backbone of the hiring process, but bad interview practices lead to bad hires. Common mistakes include:

• Asking irrelevant or illegal questions.

• Making hiring decisions based on personal bias.

• Failing to standardize interview questions.

What to do instead:

• Use structured interviews — ask every candidate the same set of questions.

• Train interviewers to focus on job-related skills.

• Take detailed notes to compare candidates objectively.

Global HR —

6 min

How to improve your interview process

5 ways to improve your interview process to hire top talent

7. Neglecting candidate experience

A poor hiring experience can damage your employer brand and turn top candidates away. If applicants feel ignored, disrespected, or left in the dark, they’ll take offers elsewhere.

What to do instead:

• Communicate clearly and frequently with candidates.

• Offer timely feedback and follow up — even with rejections.

• Create a seamless remote hiring process, from application to onboarding.

A positive candidate experience attracts top talent and strengthens your employer reputation.

8. Failing to leverage remote talent

If you’re only hiring locally, you’re missing out on top global talent. Remote hiring opens up a world of opportunities, but many companies hesitate due to outdated concerns about productivity and collaboration.

What to do instead:

• Expand hiring to global markets to access specialized talent.

• Use Remote Talent to simplify international hiring.

• Invest in remote-friendly tools to support distributed teams.

Hiring remotely gives you access to a larger, more diverse, and more skilled talent pool without increasing costs.

9. Not using data and hiring metrics 

Many companies forget to track recruitment success based on data. This results in slow, expensive, and ineffective hiring.

What to do instead:

• Track key metrics like time-to-hire, cost-per-hire, and retention rates.

• Use AI and automation to improve hiring decisions.

• Continuously optimize your hiring process using real data.

Data-driven hiring like Recruit helps you find the best candidates faster and reduce hiring mistakes.

10. Skipping reference checks

Rushing through reference checks or skipping them altogether can result in costly hiring mistakes. This oversight can also lead to legal issues if the employee's background wasn't accurately represented.

What to do instead:

• Always ask for at least two professional references.

• Ask specific, job-related questions to vet your candidate's skills.

• Use reference checkㄴ to verify the information provided by the candidate in their resume and interviews.

A thorough reference check helps confirm a candidate’s skills, work ethic, and culture fit.

Hire smarter with Remote

Hiring mistakes are expensive, but avoidable. By avoiding common mistakes and building a strong recruiting process using data, and you can create a successful team.

Better yet, a smart employment partner like Remote helps you hire and onboard top talent around the world with ease. With Remote Talent, you can post job listings on leading remote job boards, and develop cost-effective recruitment strategies to access a vast pool of qualified candidates beyond your local area.

To match with top candidates and start hiring top remote candidates, sign up for Remote Talent today.

Attract the best international talent with Remote

Get noticed by diverse, qualified candidates across the globe. Don't let geography stand in the way of hiring great people.

Sign up